Jump to content

  • Log in with Facebook Log in with Twitter Log In with Google      Sign In   
  • Join the Nation

Next Game

LIVE ON NBCSN, CBC, RDS2
Radio: WGN / iPhone / Android
THURS
05/23/2013
7:00 pm

Donations

  • Help us Score!

All of us are here for one reason: We love the Chicago Blackhawks. If you like our style, we accept beer money. Find out more information here!

Recent Status Updates

  • Photo
      23 May
    Ton DeFrancesco

    Torts is sitting Richards... lol. Here comes another axe.

    Show comments (6)
  • Photo
      20 May
    pmxclland

    No, he really didn't

    Show comments (2)
  • Photo
      20 May
    Grimsonov

    Gretzky scored 122 career playoff goals on 299 total shots. Dude shot 40.8% in the playoffs. Sick.

    Show comments (6)
  • Photo
      17 May
    The Canadian Dreamalchuk

    Soon as Subban touched the ice for team Canada they lose. Why keep allowing these Subbans to play on the national teams?

    Show comments (5)
  • Photo
      15 May
    BlackhawkPaul

    I have 2 for tonight Section 326, Row 9 Seats 3,4. Face value is $80 per. PM me an offer and they're yours.

    Show comments (7)
View All Updates

* * * - -

Corey Crawford's "Upper-body" Injury

 1261 views
This article was on The Hockey Writers |
Photo
  By Ton DeFrancesco
Corey Crawford
If Corey Crawford doesn't have a concussion, what's wrong with him? (PHOTO / US-PRESSWIRE)
During last nights game against the St. Louis Blues, Corey Crawford was caught stumbling back to the bench after the first period. The intermission rolled around and Ray Emery started in goal at the start of the 2nd period and finished the game for Crawford. So what happened?

After the game, Joel Quenneville stated that Crawford's latest upper-body injury is unrelated to his previous one, so either A. Crawford's previous injury was falsely perceived as a concussion, and this time around he truly does have one, or B. Crawford's previous injury was accurately perceived as a concussion, and this time around he does not have one.

I would lean towards answer B (no concussion), judging by Joel Quenneville's reaction. At the same time, it was not helpful when he stated: "I don't think there was a defining moment or blow."

That is also discouraging to know, suggesting that this injury could be of the lingering variety. But by stating this injury is unrelated to his previous one (widely considered a concussion), what could this mean?

I have another suggestion. What if Corey Crawford has vertigo? Surely, the Blackhawks medical staff would not clear Crawford to play if he was still suffering from a concussion, and if there was no defining moment to spark the concussion symptoms again, maybe he has a medical condition such as vertigo.

I'm not a doctor, but before Crawford left the net, he was seen hunched over. As he lifted his head it was clear that he stumbled, perhaps due to dizziness and could easily be perceived as a concussion. However, this could be identified with BPPV (benign paroxysmal positional vertigo), and it doesn't take a doctor to see that. According to Mayo Clinic, here is the main symptom of BPPV:

"Symptoms of benign paroxysmal positional vertigo are triggered by specific changes in the position of your head, such as tipping your head up or down, and by lying down, turning over or sitting up in bed. You may also feel out of balance when standing or walking." [SOURCE]

With that in mind, take a look at the footage of Corey Crawford stumbling below:


This would need to be a fairly severe concussion for him to stumble like that, and I doubt the Blackhawks doctors would clear him to play if that were the case, nor would Crawford be able to pass the concussion test.

Now maybe it's a stretch to suggest that Crawford has vertigo, but it isn't all that uncommon among NHL players. The story with Crawford sounds all too familiar with Anaheim Ducks goaltender Jonas Hiller. Hiller himself has been suffering from this condition for a few years now, although before the season started, he stated that he was symptom-free. Jeff Hackett, another goaltender diagnosed with vertigo, wasn't as lucky as Hiller and was forced to retire early.

Before anyone freaks out, all of this is pure speculation, so take it with a grain of salt. It can be something as simple as dehydration, or perhaps fatigue, although those are best case scenarios. At the same time, if Crawford's injury is kept hidden from the media, perhaps it's something we all weren't expecting. Let's hope for the best.

What do you think happened to Corey Crawford?

You should follow me on twitter here or click the button below.


  • 0

You may also like:



66 Comments | Join the discussion

I think he might be suffering from a broken record syndrome. Too much awesomeness.
    • 0
Wouldn't it be ironic if the Hawks would end up needing to acquire a goaltender, not because of them playing badly as many believed was the case before the season but because of injury. I hope it doesn't come to that and whatever is wrong with Craw will be quickly healed. With the schedule I wouldn't be surprised to see Karlsson, or whoever gets the call, playing a game or two in the near future.
    • 0
Photo
Ton DeFrancesco
Mar 01 2013 02:54 PM
BHP, I updated the original post to include the video. Thanks for pointing that out.
    • 0
It could be that Crawford has been possessed by the ghost of Steve Passmore up to this point of the season...and that was simply the spirit leaving his body.

I will try to confim this as the day goes on.
    • 2
Photo
Ton DeFrancesco
Mar 01 2013 03:46 PM

It could be that Crawford has been possessed by the ghost of Steve Passmore up to this point of the season...and that was simply the spirit leaving his body.

I will try to confim this as the day goes on.


Already confirmed by my neighbors cat. Everyone trusts cats... right?
    • 0
Right around the :14 mark...you can see him lean to his right...which is the side spirits like to exit from

You can see Corey try to fight it by reaching to his left, to keep the possession inside him
    • 0
I think he broke his penis.... it was in his upper body last night. Not good.
    • 0

Already confirmed by my neighbors cat. Everyone trusts cats... right?


NEVER trust a cat. If they were bigger they'd kill us all.
    • 0
Photo
The Count Dante
Mar 01 2013 04:33 PM

NEVER trust a cat. If they were bigger they'd kill us all.


Not if you got a can of wet food they wouldnt...
    • 0
Photo
Ton DeFrancesco
Mar 01 2013 04:33 PM
Honestly though, does anyone really believe that the medical staff would clear Crawford to play if he had such a sever concussion... to the point where he had to stumble into the tunnel? I wouldn't be so quick to believe that, unless someone hit him in the head with a bat just before the intermission.

Of course, its hard to trust Q when he talks to the media about injuries, but maybe there's something behind his statement that it's really not what we all think it is. Everyone thought it was a concussion the first time around, maybe it's not.
    • 0
Ton, you do realize that a person who received a blow to the head and therefore a concussion could takes days or weeks to show symptoms, right? They also could feel fine one minute, exert themselves in say...a NHL game, and start experiencing symptoms again.

You do know that right?
    • 0
The theory of vertigo is definitely a possibility, but it doesn't have to be BPPV. There are many other causes of vertigo as well including something as simple as an ear infection. After the game Q made it sound like Crawford is fine and will be traveling back with the team. If it was a severe concussion he likely wouldn't be allowed to fly.
    • 0
You do know...it could be dehydration/flu bug right? That goalies sweat a ridiculous amount in games...and there were IV's being seen going into the Hawks dressing room as well, right?

So..just as some are jumping to a conclusion it's a concussion 1000%....it can be something as minor as dehydration
    • 1
Photo
Ton DeFrancesco
Mar 01 2013 04:43 PM

Ton, you do realize that a person who received a blow to the head and therefore a concussion could takes days or weeks to show symptoms, right? They also could feel fine one minute, exert themselves in say...a NHL game, and start experiencing symptoms again.

You do know that right?

Yes. And phranck explained one of the many reasons why it's probably not a concussion.

The theory of vertigo is definitely a possibility, but it doesn't have to be BPPV. There are many other causes of vertigo as well including something as simple as an ear infection. After the game Q made it sound like Crawford is fine and will be traveling back with the team. If it was a severe concussion he likely wouldn't be allowed to fly.


Great observation... one of the many reasons that calling it a concussion just doesn't add up IMO. I hope it's something minor... and yes it doesn't have to be BPPV but that seems like it would be the most common among athletes.
    • 0
Photo
Ton DeFrancesco
Mar 01 2013 04:45 PM

You do know...it could be dehydration/flu bug right? That goalies sweat a ridiculous amount in games...and there were IV's being seen going into the Hawks dressing room as well, right?

So..just as some are jumping to a conclusion it's a concussion 1000%....it can be something as minor as dehydration


That's also something I started to consider over the last hour. It would be weird since he didn't really see that much work, but its possible that it could be fatigue/dehydration/flu bug... but if that were the case, Q wouldn't really call it a upper-body injury would he? Seems over-excessive to hide something minor and easily treatable.
    • 0
I don't think there's any reason for a coach to come right out after a game and tell anyone what's wrong with a guy. They have 2 more games in the next 2 1/2 days...why tell the league what's up?
    • 0
Photo
Ton DeFrancesco
Mar 01 2013 04:52 PM

I don't think there's any reason for a coach to come right out after a game and tell anyone what's wrong with a guy. They have 2 more games in the next 2 1/2 days...why tell the league what's up?


I wasn't really expecting him to come out and say anything, it's Quenneville, he never does. I just find it weird that anyone would call dehydration an upper-body injury lol. Easily could have said he's just feeling under the weather, sick, etc.. etc.. In the past he has let the media know if a guy is sick or not, he's not that bad about it. Also when a guy has been sick, they have posted it under the injury report as "flu" and I think I've even seen "dehydration/fatigue" before.

It could be something that simple, not denying that, just a weird way of going about that.
    • 0
I hear ya..

It's just some of the assumptions/accusations that the Hawks are for some reason forcing or playing guys that are concussed and don't care about their well beings ...or have them go through tests/protocals for players to pass to be sure they are 100% cleared

Hawks in the past held Toews out for the majority of last year...they are the first team to bring team physicians on the road with them...its foolish to think the Hawks would intentionall put a concussed player on the ice
    • 0
Might as well have Dr Nick figure it out.... lol

    • 0

Yes. And phranck explained one of the many reasons why it's probably POSSIBLY not a concussion.

Fixed
    • 0

I hear ya..

It's just some of the assumptions/accusations that the Hawks are for some reason forcing or playing guys that are concussed and don't care about their well beings ...or have them go through tests/protocals for players to pass to be sure they are 100% cleared

Hawks in the past held Toews out for the majority of last year...they are the first team to bring team physicians on the road with them...its foolish to think the Hawks would intentionall put a concussed player on the ice

Who is accusing/assuming? Personally, I don't think we know dick. We know what the Hawks told us: UPPER BODY INJURY. That could be all kinds of things, including a concussion,vertigo, dizziness caused by dehydration, etc.
    • 0
Global warming and or the sequester, no doubt in my mind.
    • 0

You do know...it could be dehydration/flu bug right? That goalies sweat a ridiculous amount in games...and there were IV's being seen going into the Hawks dressing room as well, right?

So..just as some are jumping to a conclusion it's a concussion 1000%....it can be something as minor as dehydration

This is exactly what i thought. Some sort of electrolyte imbalance leading to skating imbalance. It reminded me of those stupid wedding videos where one of the party just keels over after standing around doing nothing... (like Crawford was doing). I don't see anything bad coming of this (I hope).
    • 0
Photo
Ton DeFrancesco
Mar 01 2013 05:12 PM

Fixed


Lol, nice catch. I can live with that.

I hear ya..

It's just some of the assumptions/accusations that the Hawks are for some reason forcing or playing guys that are concussed and don't care about their well beings ...or have them go through tests/protocals for players to pass to be sure they are 100% cleared

Hawks in the past held Toews out for the majority of last year...they are the first team to bring team physicians on the road with them...its foolish to think the Hawks would intentionall put a concussed player on the ice


Yeah I don't think they would either. I have a hard time believing Crawford could pass a test if he can't even skate to the bench. I know that the symptoms could pop up, but I don't think I've seen a concussed player skate like that 2 weeks after the fact. Then again, I've never seen a concussed player skate two weeks after the fact because usually if they are concussed they aren't skating until they can pass the tests. Call it a catch 22, lol.

Quenneville could be lying to the media (or so some think), sure, but if there is slight truth in him saying (paraphrasing here) "there wasn't a defining moment" in when he got injured, then it brings some light on a situation where Crawford was dehydrated. On the flip side, that also could fit in with vertigo too.

Which I will say, I don't think Quenneville outright lies to the media, I think he just doesn't release a lot of information. If you read between the lines though, sometimes you can figure it out.
    • 0
Corey Crawford on the ice this morning.......Anyone still think it was concussion symptoms?
Also, I doubt it was dehydration. It takes extreme levels of dehydration to get to that point. Unless he also had massive diarrhea/vomiting all day it's very unlikely it was dehydration.
    • 0